top of page

Comparing Free Weights and Machines: Which is Superior for Muscle and Strength Development?

There is a considerable amount of contradictory information regarding whether machines or free weights are more effective in assisting individuals in reaching their fitness objectives.


There is often a debate among fitness experts about machines versus free weights, but it doesn't necessarily have to be a choice between the two. In most cases, machines and free weights provide an equal level of effectiveness for muscle growth as they both exert force on your muscles.


The choice of exercises will always vary based on the individual's exercise background, capabilities, and objectives. Additionally, how specific exercises are performed may differ among individuals due to factors such as height, limb length, and torso length. These variations can affect the intensity of muscle engagement in different areas.


Let's say that when you do a squat, the length of your thigh and shin bones will have a significant impact on how upright or bent over you are while you lower into the exercise. It might be necessary to adjust the squat or consider opting for a different exercise, such as a hack squat or leg press.


Is it necessary to choose between free weights and machines, or can they both be beneficial in different ways? Let's delve deeper into this.



How do free weights and machines differ from each other?


Free weight exercises are characterized by an unrestricted range of motion and a greater demand for stability during the movement.


During a dumbbell chest press, you exert force to lift the weight while simultaneously preventing it from moving sideways. Machines offer resistance by following a predetermined path of movement and are typically more stable compared to exercises using free weights.



What is more effective for promoting muscle growth?


Studies indicate that the body cannot sink between using machines or free weights during weightlifting, as it solely perceives the resistance and muscle tension required to move the load. As a result, both methods can exert comparable stress levels to promote muscle growth.


Do free weights offer greater functionality?


The term 'functional' is frequently used by individuals to indicate that exercise has a more remarkable ability to transfer to the requirements of everyday life, such as household tasks or lifting objects. Luckily, movements do not need to imitate real life to be effective, meaning no exercises are considered 'ineffective.' Improving can be achieved simply by becoming stronger.



What advantages does training with free weights offer?


Although there is often a debate among fitness experts about the superiority of free weights versus machine exercises, both options offer distinct benefits that can guide your decision on when and where to incorporate them into your workout routine.


The power lifts benefit more from using free weights.


To enhance strength in a specific movement, it is most effective to train that particular movement, as stated by the principle of specificity. If you have goals focused on building strength at the gym, such as increasing how much you can squat, it is essential to prioritize squatting over other exercises.


However, it is essential to note that focusing solely on these lifts is not recommended, as various factors influence the amount of weight you can lift, such as muscle size, which can be enhanced through machine exercises.


There is a greater range of variation in most free-weight exercises.


Although it is not valid in every situation, most free-weight exercises offer the opportunity to diversify your training by adjusting factors such as grip width. For example, you can compare a close-grip bench press to a conventional grip bench press. You can intentionally modify your specific focus in an exercise using these variations. If your goal is to tone your arms, performing a close-grip bench press can be beneficial as it requires your triceps to exert more effort than a regular bench press.


If you exercise at home, it is more practical to use free weights.


If you have limited space at home, free weights are generally more practical for training in almost any situation. With just a few pieces of equipment, such as a barbell, dumbbells, a rack, and a bench, you can engage in numerous whole-body workouts. On the other hand, machines confine you to a specific range of motion and are typically less adaptable, necessitating multiple devices to train your entire body effectively. This not only requires more space but also results in higher average costs.



The advantages of engaging in machine-based training.


Typically, machine exercises are considered to be safer.


Machines are generally considered safer than free weights because they require less skill and motor control, resulting in fewer accidents and injuries. Also, when it comes to machine exercises, it is generally safer to train closer to the point of failure. This is because the risk of your technique deteriorating and leading to failure is significantly reduced. This is advantageous because it is more probable for your muscles to give out rather than your technique, which is essential for sculpting your physique.


Performing intensity techniques is more efficient when using machine exercises.


According to research, intensity techniques such as rest-pause and drop sets effectively promote muscle growth. When it comes to these movements, machines might be a better choice since they allow for a faster weight reduction or quick handling of implements. Performing this task is typically more straightforward when using machines, particularly those that have pin-loaded features.


On the other hand, when performing a drop set with exercises like bench press or dumbbell press, you need to unrack and re-rack weights every time you lower the weight due to fatigue. Additionally, you have to set yourself up again to execute the exercise. Therefore, this leads to additional time and increased fatigue compared to just adjusting the pin on a machine stack, making machine exercises more appropriate for the task.


Free-weight exercises do not have as good resistance profiles as specific machine exercises.


A resistance profile essentially indicates the part of a lift that is the most difficult and the easiest or the part where you need to apply the most and least amount of force. During a barbell Romanian deadlift, the difficulty of the exercise increases as you descend and decreases as you ascend.


The significance of this lies in that specific machines are designed with resistance profiles that align with your strengths and weaknesses during a lift. Research has demonstrated that this can positively affect muscle growth and contribute to developing all sections of a specific muscle.


In simple terms, when your muscles are contracted, such as at the top of a barbell hip thrust, when you tighten your glutes, they can generate less force. On the other hand, your muscles can generate the highest amount of power when they are in a middle position, like when your forearms are parallel to the floor during a standing bicep curl.


This biomechanical aspect is reflected in specific exercise machines.


If I have just started lifting weights, what should I do?


Is it true that many personal trainers and fitness experts suggest that beginners begin with machine exercises before progressing to free weights due to the lower level of skill needed?


Yes, in the majority of circumstances. Many novice weightlifters struggle with the coordination needed to contract their muscles properly. Furthermore, the consistent movement of machines allows for a greater ability to push oneself without the concern of deteriorating technique. According to research, the primary reason beginners experience strength gains is their improved ability to contract muscles effectively rather than actual muscle growth. Therefore, machines are an excellent starting point.


The Big Takeaway


Although there is often a debate among fitness experts about the superiority of free weights versus machine exercises, both options offer distinct benefits that can guide your decision on when and where to incorporate them into your workout routine. Furthermore, by letting go of preconceived notions about which option is superior, you open yourself up to a broader range of exercise choices. This enables you to make personalized decisions aligning with your needs and objectives.


Main Points to Remember


  • A false contradiction is often created by numerous fitness experts who compare and contrast free-weight exercises with machine exercises.


  • Exercises that involve free weights are not limited in their range of motion.


  • The range of motion in machine exercises is fixed and takes the stability out of the movement, making it more effective for targeting a specific muscle.


  • According to research, there is no significant difference in muscle growth between using machines and free weights when considering all factors.


  • The type of equipment you use for lifting, whether it's machines or free weights, doesn't matter to your muscles. They only feel the resistance that is being provided.


  • The main trigger for muscle growth is mechanical tension.


  • The exercise selection process should consider individual factors such as injury history, biomechanics, and goals.


  • Machine exercises not only enhance strength but also boost functional capacity.


  • The benefits of free weight exercises include their ability to improve performance in power lifts, their versatility for different workout routines, and their convenience for home workouts.


  • Machine exercises offer several benefits, such as enhanced safety, reduced skill demands, and increased practicality when incorporating intensity techniques.


  • Machine exercises can benefit new lifters by effectively stimulating their muscles, especially when their neuromuscular efficiency is still relatively lower.

Comments


About

My name is Steven Goldstein

With over 10 years of experience in the fitness industry, I have worked with clients of all ages and fitness levels. From professional athletes to individuals aiming to lose weight, I have helped countless people achieve their goals and improve their overall health through customized training and nutrition plans.

Untitled design(18).png

Consistency leaves clues

Hundreds of clients of all ages, backgrounds, and abilities have put their health in our hands over the years and achieved truly remarkable results. 

bottom of page